on
30
September
2019
Jeremy the confused gorilla. If you’re a Jeremy, trying to work out what you’re doing with hiring - read on! If you’re a Jeremy in other aspects of your life, probably we’re limited in what we can do, but we recommend having a glass of water and a little nap. (If your name is actually Jeremy, hi Jezza! Great name!)

Where do you begin with hiring? 

Hiring is hard. Hiring the right people is even harder. If you’ve been tasked with rapidly growing your team, or improving diversity in the workplace, you’ll understand the pressure of finding quality candidates quickly. 

Once you have the role fleshed out and the job ad nailed, you’ll want to find places to post that aren’t a huge rip-off, but are efficient and actually work. Places that show you off to a diverse range of candidates with talent and help you make a difficult choice a little less difficult. That’s why job boards exist, right?


What’s the problem with job boards?

Look at all these people applying for your job. Aren’t you glad you handed over all them squids for the pleasure of ruining your eyesight on CVs and cover letters. No? Oh, well. Read on then.

Job boards take your money, and give you back a flood of potential candidates - great! 

Oh, but wait. Most of these people aren’t suitable, and those left over are difficult to differentiate. Job boards aren’t strategic about who they send your roles towards. For traditional job boards, volume = success and each person who applies for a role is the same as the next. 

It’s also impossible to work out which job boards are most effective for your needs. If you’re finding developers for your start-up or trying to hire STEM women, or generally looking for more diverse recruitment methods, there’s no way of knowing who is looking where.

This means that all these important hiring decisions you’re making end up being based on gut instinct - and your gut tends to get things wrong.

Traditional job boards are not data-driven. We think we can do things better.

The science behind why Applied is the best

We care about making decisions based on actual information. This is why we’ve created a smart league table, ranking job boards across diversity hiring and average scores in the first stage of our application process.

Ain’t she a beauty. Yep, we’re pretty proud of ourselves. Look at how superior our job board league table is to every other job board league table. What’s that? We’re the only one? (You don’t have to be smug to work at Applied, but it will certainly happen to you after you’ve been here a few weeks)


All the data we used comes from the Applied platform, so we’re pretty sure it’s the most unbiased hiring performance data in the world. 

Being vigorous in our methods is important to us. We waited until we had a big enough pool of applications driven from job boards to collect data - ensuring our results would be meaningful. Here they are!

Our findings:

Gender

We saw huge variability between top job boards in numbers of male vs female applicants. As an example, our data shows that Advance Careers provided over 82% female applicants, compared to Totaljobs at 74% male.

Here are our top 5 Job boards for Gender Diversity

Ethnicity

Across 47 ethnic categories, we broadly saw similar results in our whole dataset, and from job boards. For those looking to improve graduate BAME recruitment, university job boards saw a higher proportion of applicants who identified as Asian, and a lower proportion of black applicants. 

Here are our top 5 Job Boards for Ethnic Diversity.

Age

If we exclude university job boards, we saw a higher proportion of older applicants (over the age of 30). It’s too early to tell, but this maybe suggests that younger candidates are finding out about roles through less traditional mediums - like Twitter, for example, or other social media channels. 

Disability 

Candidates from job boards were more likely than candidates from other sources to declare a disability but they were also more likely to decline to answer or to leave this field blank.

Quality 

This is a tricky one! To get a snapshot on “quality” applicants, we compared the average scores in Applied’s first assessment stage for candidates from job boards, to all candidates who applied for the same jobs. 

Using this data, we found that generic job boards performed poorly.

For example, candidates from Guardian Jobs had an average review score of 2.44 against 2.82 for all review scores (on a grading scale of 1-5). One potential explanation is that people apply via generic job boards while browsing jobs generally, rather than because they have a real affinity for the role. These people are less likely to look at niche jobs boards targeted at, say, finding app developer roles or roles for women or BAME in tech. 

Disclaimer
Remember that the best candidates could come from literally anywhere. While being smarter about where you put your job ads (and yo money) is important, so is having an open mind. 

What’s next?

Here’s a stock image of some beautiful charts and infographics, because everyone likes data and also because I was once told that including photos like this makes people think we’re smart - which we are - but it makes people think we are too. Possibly also does something to offset all the gorilla photos.


We know we’re pretty great - but part of that is knowing where we can do better. 

Our first stab at this job boards business already includes information that traditional job boards can’t give you - *cough* actual data *cough* - but we have lots of other ideas. 

One potential tweak is improving our table to include the average score of candidates from each job board COMPARED to the average for the role they were applying for. We also want to provide richer insights for different roles, skill-sets, seniority levels and more. 

Our mission is to incorporate data and remove bias from every part of the recruitment process. This can begin with you knowing the best job boards for fairer, smarter hiring. 

So, where do we begin with hiring? By digging in a little deeper and gathering insights on the platforms that will give you the results you want: diverse and talented applicants, interested in you.

Jeremy the astounded gorilla who now has a MUCH better idea how to advertise for diversity and talent. If you’re confused-Jezza or astounded-Jezza, get in touch! We love to hear from our gorilla friends, wherever they fall on the enlightenment spectrum. All gorillas welcome.


Want to know which job boards to post your jobs to get better and more diverse candidates? Here are our top-performing job boards:

Top 5 Job boards for Gender Diversity

Top 5 Job Boards for Ethnic Diversity

Top 5 Job Boards for Startup Roles